Listen on Spotify Apple Music Amazon Music

Budgets are meant to be about clear figures: growth, inflation, unemployment, headroom. Instead, this week on Westminster Insider, Sascha and Pat pull back the curtain on the thin evidence that passes for Britain’s economic data — and show how much of government policy looks more like guesswork and political spin than hard measurement.

Sascha speaks with Dr Laura Gilbert, the former director of data at Number 10 Downing Street, who lays out why the official numbers on things like immigration and the workforce can be out by hundreds of thousands. When the foundations of decisions are that shaky, it’s little wonder policies wobble.

Ben Warner, who served as chief adviser on data and digital at Number 10 during the pandemic, explains why those gaps in the data create chaos for decision-making. He argues — plausibly — that many ministers don’t really understand how to use the information they’re given, and that too often political narratives fill the gaps where rigorous analysis should be.