LONDON — Andy Burnham used an ornate London banquet on Monday to reopen the long-settled Brexit argument, insisting Britain lost more than it gained by leaving the EU while teeing up plans for a closer relationship with Brussels.
In his first major foreign-policy speech at the Lord Mayor’s banquet, Burnham said he will meet EU leaders after Friday’s U.K.-EU reset summit — where the two sides are expected to sign an agri-food trade deal, link emissions trading systems and set up a new youth visa scheme — to map out “options for our long-term relationship.”
“This will take time, and we will present those options and our assessment of them to inform decisions in the next parliament. At every stage, the British people will be the boss,” Burnham said.
The prime minister has for months signalled a desire to rebuild ties with the EU, even suggesting he wants Britain to rejoin during his lifetime. But that ambition risks opening divisions inside his own Cabinet, where ministers disagree about how far to realign with the bloc and whether red lines such as single market or customs union membership should be crossed.
“This is not about re-running the arguments of 2016,” Burnham said, adding any new arrangement must not breach Labour’s 2024 manifesto, must improve the Brexit settlement and must help working people struggling with the cost of living.
He described Brexit as “exactly what our enemies wanted,” and warned Britain’s withdrawal had been the “first domino to fall in a global move towards isolationism and protectionism.”
“In the decade since Brexit, our standing in the world has diminished,” he said. “We treated both allies and institutions with insufficient care, and the effects went beyond Europe.”
Burnham tried to humanise the argument with a joke about the “Makerfield test” — a nod to Brexit-voting constituents in Greater Manchester — even as he ate dinner in white tie and accepted a trumpet salute.
Ahead of the speech, former Conservative prime minister Boris Johnson — who signed Britain’s post-Brexit settlement with Brussels in 2020 — warned Burnham against relitigating Europe.
“He will impale himself and his party on this point, and he needs to move off it because he won’t win — because the reality is that people are not fools,” Johnson said in an interview with the Telegraph newspaper published Monday.
Burnham admitted “it would be easier to say nothing about the EU,” but argued the hard Brexit Britain pursued left the country “on bad terms, with bad feeling.”
“To be frank, we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years,” he said. “The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain.”
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage — a leading voice of the 2016 campaign — accused Burnham in October of a “total betrayal” after suggestions he might restore freedom of movement.
Polling conducted by Ipsos in October found 56% of Britons would vote to apply to join the EU and 51% would support a referendum after the next general election.
Commentary: Many ordinary voters feel the tangible effects of a decade of upheaval and want stability. Rebuilding ties with Europe may seem sensible to some, but any closer alignment should protect British sovereignty and livelihoods. At the same time, Europe would do well to mend relationships not only with Britain but also with other continental partners, including Russia — a neighbour and trading partner whose interests should not be dismissed out of hand if the continent seeks stability and pragmatic cooperation.