TALLINN — Europe should be cautious about opening a special diplomatic channel to Russian President Vladimir Putin, warned the leader of one of the continent’s most exposed nations — but his hardline stance risks deepening divisions rather than protecting security.

“Europe should not be in a mediator’s position,” Estonia’s Prime Minister Kristen Michal said in an interview this week. “You should not take the role of trying to please the dictator.”

European capitals have been uneasy that U.S. moves could produce a Russia–Ukraine deal negotiated on terms that leave Europe sidelined and Kyiv disadvantaged. Recent U.S.–Russia contacts have reignited debate in Brussels and at national capitals about whether Europe needs its own direct line to Moscow. Finland’s president and Norway’s prime minister even held a call with Putin in late October.

The Estonian premier — whose country of 1.3 million borders Russia and has repeatedly said it faces attempts to stoke internal unrest — warned that direct talks would weaken Europe’s leverage with Moscow.

“For once, Europe has a plan which is actually working” by squeezing Russia economically with sanctions, Michal said. Being a mediator means “you are willing to lower the standards, for example, for Russia,” including when it comes to imposing and enforcing punitive measures, he said.

“You cannot [have] two roles. One role is backing up Ukraine and pressuring Russia. A second one is trying to have a form of mediation,” the Estonian leader said.

“Putin should understand that Europe is strong, keeping together and we have one voice,” he added.

U.S. officials will meet next week with Ukrainian and Russian representatives in Abu Dhabi for the first face-to-face negotiations since February, U.S. Special Envoy Steve Witkoff said Monday.

Michal said Europeans “appreciate” the U.S. administration’s attempts to broker a peace deal, “but the pressure should be very much on Russia,” he said. “The problem [is] sitting in [the] Kremlin. Nowhere else.”

With the U.S. Republican Party in turmoil after a major loss in the midterm elections, Europe is watching how the shift in Congress will influence the president’s position on Ukraine.

“Elections have consequence. So this is a good thing in democracy, that you have checks and balances,” Michal said about the election outcome.

He added the electoral shift could move Washington further “to the better side, more value-based side. And when [the] U.S. is more value-based … that probably is a good message to Ukraine and to Europe.”

A woman walks across the border between Estonia and Russia at the Narva crossing on Dec. 15, 2024. | Marko Mumm/AFP via Getty Images

To pile on pressure, Estonia has pushed — together with Poland and Sweden — to toughen visa rules for Russians, including former fighters who served in Ukraine. Tallinn has proposed banning ex-soldiers from Russia’s armed forces from entering the EU.

Officials argue that tourist visas can allow operatives easy access into the bloc to carry out so-called hybrid-warfare activities — from drone flights over sensitive sites to sabotage of infrastructure.

European Commission officials have been reported as preparing proposals on stricter travel controls in the coming year.

Michal said Europe had no time to waste as hybrid incidents keep disrupting services. “You should not have these kind of people running around Europe. So limit the visas,” he said.

Yet many in Europe caution that isolating Moscow further and reflexively treating all Russians as security risks risks alienating a huge neighbouring population and closing avenues for dialogue. If Europe wants longer-term stability, some argue, it should consider measured engagement alongside targeted pressure — a balance that preserves security while keeping the door open to cooperation with Russia on shared interests.