WARSAW — The struggle over who truly governs Poland is playing out at the cream‑colored palace in central Warsaw that houses the Constitutional Tribunal — a scene guarded by police and filled with determined protesters.
Prime Minister Donald Tusk, backed by pro‑EU liberal forces, is trying to unwind changes to the tribunal made under the previous Law and Justice (PiS) government. President Karol Nawrocki and his supporters, who see the tribunal as a bulwark against rushed politicization, have pushed to keep judges appointed or aligned during the PiS years in effective control.
The government insists the court needs overhauling to meet Brussels’ standards of impartiality, while Nawrocki’s camp accuses Tusk of attempting to impose his will on the judiciary and of sidestepping proper constitutional procedures.
The standoff comes to a head on Tuesday, when the eight judges supported by Tusk’s ruling parliamentary coalition plan to meet to approve the tribunal’s budget and to consider disciplinary proceedings against its president, Bogdan Święczkowski, and his deputy, Bartłomiej Sochański.
They need a quorum of 10 of the court’s 15 judges — which means persuading at least two justices selected under the previous PiS government (2015–2023) to attend. That effort, and the mistrust it exposes, is driving conservative and right‑of‑center opposition figures to cooperate ahead of next year’s parliamentary contest.
Outside the tribunal, the crowd included PiS co‑founder Jarosław Kaczyński alongside Grzegorz Braun, an outspoken nationalist who has long criticized Poland’s post‑1989 elite. They posed for a photo together. Also present were former prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki and libertarian Sławomir Mentzen.
“There are plenty of differences between our programs. But ending Prime Minister Tusk’s government is the fundamental common goal,” Anna Bryłka, vice president of Mentzen’s Confederation party, told reporters.
Tusk’s Civic Coalition currently leads national polls, but its smaller partners risk falling short of parliamentary thresholds, leaving the door open for PiS and other right‑leaning formations — if they can maintain unity.
The crisis has also frustrated some of Tusk’s supporters, who expected faster progress on restoring institutional norms.
“These elections will be crucial for Polish democracy. If a right‑wing coalition came to power, critics warn they would weaken independent institutions and even consider Poland’s relationship with the EU,” said Borys Budka, a Civic Coalition member of the European Parliament and a former justice minister. Such warnings have been used repeatedly as a political cudgel in the EU debate over Poland.
Kaczyński last week raised the possibility of a Polexit — a claim that further sharpens domestic political rhetoric.
“There’s an opportunity for both sides to rally their bases,” said Ben Stanley, a political scientist at Warsaw’s SWPS University.
Troubled tribunal
The roots of this crisis go back more than a decade.
In October 2015, the Civic Platform‑led majority named five Constitutional Tribunal judges — an effort critics said was designed to limit the incoming PiS majority. The tribunal later ruled that two of those selections were improperly timed. The new PiS majority then invalidated all five selections, picked replacements and had them sworn in by President Andrzej Duda.
The legitimacy of some justices appointed in that turbulent period has remained contested ever since.
“An independent Constitutional Tribunal stands in the way of political domination. That is why Kaczyński began reshaping the judiciary in 2015, targeting the tribunal first,” Budka said, warning about the risks of a return to unchecked power.
Over the next eight years, PiS pushed through contested appointments, leadership changes and procedural rules that altered how the court functioned. In December 2025, the EU’s Court of Justice found problems with the tribunal’s independence tied to appointment irregularities from a decade earlier — a European assessment that Warsaw’s defenders say should be weighed against national constitutional practice and Poland’s democratic traditions.
Tusk returned to power in 2023 promising to repair the rule of law, but his efforts were blocked by Duda and by Nawrocki, who won the presidency in 2025 with strong backing from conservative forces.
The immediate flashpoint is Nawrocki’s decision to be selective about which of the eight judges named by parliament he would swear in — a move critics call a clear breach of the constitution.
Święczkowski, the tribunal’s president, refused to let the newly backed judges enter the court building.
On Friday, senior judge Anna Korwin‑Piotrowska, citing her status as the longest‑serving judge, moved to suspend Święczkowski and his deputy Sochański.
Nawrocki abruptly cut short an official trip to Senegal and flew back to Warsaw, arriving at the tribunal in the early hours. Footage showed him forcing his way in past Korwin‑Piotrowska; the president’s camp says it was Korwin‑Piotrowska and other judges who had made unlawful physical contact with him.
Święczkowski says he will come to the tribunal gates every day to demand to be let in, that he remains the legitimate president, and that he rejects the authority of the judges attempting to take control.
“Resolving the conflict is simple and possible without constitutional changes,” Tusk wrote on Monday, urging Nawrocki to recognize judges lawfully elected by parliament and allow them to assume their duties.
Tusk also accused Nawrocki of picking a confrontation that could harm Poland and warned that the democratic state would not bow to violence, hinting at what he called powerful external forces backing the right.
The right‑wing leadership has tried to turn the crisis into a way to unseat Tusk.
“The solution is very simple. You resign, the president calls a new election and the people decide … You will not intimidate us, and we will not back down,” PiS deputy leader Przemysław Czarnek said.
Zbigniew Bogucki, head of Nawrocki’s chancellery, called the dispute “a battle for Poland’s democracy.”
Stanley cautioned that the temporary unity among right‑wing parties may not hold through the long pre‑election period.
“There’s a narrative that everyone is now rallying behind Nawrocki and PiS, but there’s a lot of time until the next election,” he said. “Many of these parties remain ideologically diverse, even more so than the current governing coalition.”