LONDON — Defence Secretary Wes Streeting insisted Friday that Andy Burnham will not impose “arbitrary” cuts on Britain’s rising social security bill, defending days of muddled government messaging on welfare and arguing the country deserves a considered, practical approach.

Streeting accused Labour’s opponents — and the Keir Starmer government he once served in as health secretary — of failing to properly think through how to bring down the welfare bill, which led to a collapse of support for earlier plans.

He told the BBC Today programme: “I saw it, frankly, after the last general election, when we went too far too fast with an arbitrary figure to cut welfare and when people saw the detail of what that meant for disabled people in our country, the very same people who were saying we need to cut the welfare bill were saying ‘but not like that’.

“What I do understand from experience, and I’ve seen this experience borne out under both Conservative and Labour governments, is that when you put in place arbitrary targets to cut welfare without a thought-through plan to do so sustainably and responsibly, the plans fall apart.”

Spending on U.K. health and disability-related benefits has risen sharply since the Covid pandemic, with the bill for working-age disability benefits in England and Wales increasing from £14bn in 2020 to £25bn in 2026.

Former Health Secretary Alan Milburn is leading a report on how to help the estimated one million young people not in employment or education; it is due in November. The government is also waiting on minister Stephen Timms to make recommendations on disability benefit reform.

A previous attempt under Starmer to cut welfare was abandoned after a revolt among Labour MPs, a row that damaged the leader’s authority and suggested the party leadership had lost touch with rank-and-file MPs.

Streeting’s remarks followed an extended back-and-forth between ministers and journalists on Thursday over whether Burnham’s government will reduce welfare spending before the next general election.

Chancellor Rachel Reeves was asked by the BBC on Thursday whether cuts to the welfare bill would come before the next election. “There will be a reduction in the benefits bill, we’ll do that in a Labour way,” she said.

But Treasury officials moved quickly to clarify that Reeves had not set a date for reductions, with the chancellor later telling Channel 4 News: “It’s not correct to say that we are going to bring this welfare bill down in this parliament because we’ve not set a timetable for that.”

Streeting said on Friday: “We all agree we’ve got to bring it down, we’ve just got to do it in the right way.”

The Conservatives seized on the confusion, accusing Labour of being “confused, unserious, and [having] no plan.”

Deputy Conservative Chairman Matt Vickers told GB News Friday morning that the chancellor had given “no answers” on welfare, adding: “The government’s priorities are completely wrong. We need to get in there, sort the ballooning welfare bill, and protect this country properly.”