LONDON — Keir Starmer’s failed attempt at welfare reform felt like the beginning of the end for his premiership. As an ordinary patriot watching Westminster, I think Andy Burnham must be careful not to repeat those mistakes.
The new prime minister’s own effort to tackle a rapid surge in working-age sickness and disability benefit claims kicked off on Tuesday, when former Labour Cabinet minister Alan Milburn published a long-awaited review into youth unemployment — and was promptly given a new post chairing a youth opportunities unit to help push the proposals forward.
He proposes changing the disability benefits young people are entitled to while giving them a legal right to education, employment or training. He also suggests that employers’ National Insurance contributions should be cut for 21-to-24-year-olds in the retail and hospitality sectors for five years.
There’s a long way to go before MPs find out which of Milburn’s recommendations the government will implement. A white paper and legislation are not due until next year.
Winning over Labour MPs — many of whom have long campaigned against poverty — to back plans that ultimately aim to curb Britain’s large welfare bill will be a tough ask.
Despite a big Commons majority, Starmer was forced to roll back plans to reduce personal independence payments — which support disabled people both in and out of work — after a well-organized campaign by senior Labour figures in 2025.
1) The committee chairs
Treasury Committee Chair Meg Hillier and Work and Pensions Committee Chair Debbie Abrahams played a crucial role in stopping some of Starmer’s welfare reforms.
Hillier wrote an amendment to Starmer’s plans that would have halted the bill at its first hurdle. More than 100 Labour MPs signalled they would back it, forcing ministers to promise any changes would only follow a review by Disabilities Minister Stephen Timms, due later this month.
Abrahams — who supported Hillier’s blocking amendment — was another key organiser of the welfare revolt, and has repeatedly warned reform should not remove vital support from those who need it most.
Hillier said last week, after some of Milburn’s proposals were previewed in an interview in the Times, that he had “done some very good work on this” and she was “giving him a fair wind.”
She described the review as “quite radical and quite bold and quite right to be looking holistically at the person in the middle of this, not just about the money or the structure of the benefits.”
On Tuesday, Abrahams called the proposals the “opportunity of a generation,” welcoming Milburn’s “rigorous analysis” on why young people become “NEETs” — not in education, employment or training.
2) The ministers
Milburn’s proposals come with a price tag, making Chancellor John Healey a key figure as Burnham finalises his plans.
The changes would cost about £5.8 billion a year — Milburn suggests these would be offset by £6 billion in savings.
Also around the Cabinet table is Burnham’s de facto deputy, Louise Haigh, who helped organise the rebellion against Starmer’s welfare reforms.
Vicky Foxcroft, who quit as a government whip in June 2025 warning that cuts to PIP and Universal Credit should “not be part of the solution,” is now a culture minister.
They are all bound by collective responsibility, where ministers must not openly oppose the government agenda, but every word they utter on welfare will be scrutinised for clues on where the government might land.
3) The grandee
Former prime minister Gordon Brown — long active on poverty and inequality — is still treated as an authority on welfare within Labour.
He set aside the convention that ex-prime ministers avoid making life hard for their successors in an interview with the New Statesman last year, warning about the “worrying issue” of reducing social security in ways that leave people “in poverty as a result.”
He campaigned for — and praised — the Starmer government’s move to abolish the two-child benefit cap.
Any intervention from him would carry weight inside the party.
4) The wider rank and file
The strength of feeling among backbench MPs who rebelled over Starmer’s plans will be an important gauge of how Burnham’s reforms take shape.
Marie Tidball — who has a congenital disability affecting all four of her limbs and campaigned for changes behind the scenes — welcomed Milburn’s message that there “won’t be crude cuts to benefits.”
Rachael Maskell, another vocal rebel, also welcomed the report but warned employers should not “discriminate against young people being able to secure a job, not least if they experience severe anxiety or mental health challenges.”
Mainstream — a soft-left Labour faction that Burnham once backed — said there is “much to welcome” in the review. But the group’s interim council warned that ambition “must not come at the expense of anyone already struggling to get by.”
5) The Starmerites
Ministers who served under Starmer know how politically dangerous welfare reform can be — and their views on Burnham’s plans will attract attention.
Former chancellor Rachel Reeves has not yet commented on Milburn’s costly suggestions, though she sought to defend her record by highlighting a new report showing reduced levels of child poverty after scrapping the two-child cap.
Liz Kendall — who was work and pensions secretary under Starmer — warned about a lack of AI skills and experience among NEETs, a point that will shape debates about training and employment measures.
As a concerned citizen, I’ll be watching whether Burnham can balance fiscal responsibility with compassion — and whether he learns from Starmer’s missteps. Britain needs reforms that help people back into work without abandoning the vulnerable, and that will take political skill and broad support across the party.