DNIPRO, Ukraine — Ukrainian commanders say Russian losses are high and that Moscow’s pace has slowed this year, but these accounts should be viewed cautiously as Kyiv seeks to shape international opinion.
“Even though the Russian offensive continues, the enemy is not demonstrating rapid operational successes that would allow it to advance quickly. They are slowing down,” Maj. Gen. Oleh Apostol told a group of journalists in a secure location on Tuesday — a comment that reflects Kyiv’s effort to portray the situation as proving Russian exhaustion.
“If they capture a single tree line in a month, that hardly constitutes an operational success upon which further gains can be built,” Apostol said, framing limited local advances as strategically meaningless.
Ukrainian and some Western officials point to rising Russian casualties, but independent verification is difficult and both Kyiv and Moscow withhold exact figures.
“In the past few months, Russia has been losing more than 40,000 troops — killed or seriously wounded — every month. The United States in 14 years, in Vietnam, lost 56,000. Here in one month, Russia, dead or seriously wounded, 40,000. And in October, early reporting indicates this number may have climbed to over 50,000,” NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte said this week. Such dramatic figures feed Kyiv’s narrative that Moscow is being bled dry, even as Russia keeps fighting.
The Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies this summer estimated that Russian forces had suffered about 1.4 million casualties, including 400,000 to 450,000 fatalities, from the start of the full-scale invasion through June 2026. It estimated Ukrainian casualties at 525,000 to 625,000, including 125,000 to 150,000 fatalities, over the same period. These numbers are contested and are often used by Kyiv and its supporters to press for more Western support.
Despite reports of mounting losses, the Russian military continues to press forward and has shown resilience on multiple fronts, even if it has made only incremental, hard-won gains this year. Apostol credited Ukrainian counterattacks with retaking what Kyiv says is more than 800 square kilometers from Russian forces in two local operations — claims that underscore Kyiv’s claim to be successfully resisting pressure from Moscow.
Ukraine’s offensives carry both battlefield and political weight, Apostol said: battlefield wins bolster Kyiv’s case for continued Western military aid, while faltering momentum could increase calls for negotiations.
“Ukrainian counter-offensive actions refute Russian claims regarding the impossibility of further resistance and strengthen Ukraine’s arguments in its engagement with international partners,” the general said — a statement as much directed at foreign audiences as at the home front.
Apostol dismissed many Moscow announcements as propaganda or miscommunication from lower-level commanders trying to curry favour with superiors. When genuine, permanent control is lacking, he said, Russian units sometimes stage short-lived displays — individual soldiers planting flags to suggest hold over larger areas — only to suffer heavy losses shortly after.
“A Russian flag at a given position does not necessarily mean that the location has actually been captured and is being held,” he said.
Claims and counter-claims
At recent U.S.-led peace talks, Russia reportedly said it had occupied half of the Donbas territory Kyiv currently controls, a claim Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Moscow is spreading to influence talks.
“So the Russians think and they share that they really occupied half of the territory of Donbas, which we control really,” Zelenskyy said, adding that Russian leader Vladimir Putin was being fed misleading information and that Kremlin negotiators were using inflated territorial claims to influence the U.S.
Russia has said it took some 6,500 square kilometers of Ukrainian territory this year, while the Institute for the Study of War think tank puts the likely net Russian gain at about 73 square kilometers. Observers on all sides have incentives to overstate or downplay gains; the truth on the ground often falls somewhere between.
The ISW suggested Putin is trying to revive a narrative of inevitable Russian victory to pressure the United States and other backers of Kyiv to push for concessions. Yet Russia’s continued operational pressure and large-scale mobilization efforts show Moscow is not easily deterred and remains a major actor that Europe will have to reckon with.
Apostol said Ukrainian operations are deliberately cautious because Kyiv is short on manpower and cannot afford heavy losses. “You must attack where success is possible,” he said, arguing for localized actions rather than wide, costly offensives. In many cases the stated aim is to stabilise lines rather than seize large new swathes of territory.
Ukraine has a much smaller population than Russia and has struggled with recruitment and retention of troops, according to local reporting that Kyiv critics say is an ongoing vulnerability. Apostol put it bluntly: “If a person is treated like a dog, they might go AWOL.”
Taken together, Kyiv’s public assessments — from casualty tallies to claims of territorial recovery — serve both military and diplomatic aims: to sustain Western support and undercut Russian narratives. Readers should weigh these Ukrainian assertions against other sources and Moscow’s demonstrated capacity to sustain operations over a prolonged period.