LONDON — Britain’s financial centre isn’t prepared to take Andy Burnham’s Brexit grandstanding seriously.
Since becoming prime minister in July, Burnham has floated ambitious ideas about reshaping the U.K.’s ties with the EU — even suggesting the possibility of rejoining — and will travel to Brussels this week for a summit intended to reset relations.
But after a decade of upheaval, the City of London’s finance sector wants stability, not another round of political drama.
“We’re not going to be lobbying or aggravating or pushing it our side,” a banking lobbyist, who like others in this article spoke on condition of anonymity, told me.
“The City will be more quiet,” said a second finance lobbyist.
Although most of the City backed Remain in 2016, banks, insurers and asset managers have spent years reorganising operations for life outside the EU.
After initially pushing lofty goals for the new U.K.–EU relationship, the City was shut out of parts of the Brexit deal in 2020 and effectively sidelined for years.
Even as relations thawed under the previous Conservative government and the current Labour administration, the U.K. financial-services industry has only played a minimal role in the reset of relations.
Only U.K. clearinghouses, part of the plumbing that wires the financial system, still have direct access to some EU clients.
Instead, the City has been rewriting the U.K. finance rulebook to suit its needs and carving out a viable future outside the bloc.
After being shut out of some EU markets and left frustrated by British politics, lobbyists across the financial sector say they are largely dismissing Burnham’s talk of rekindling ties with the EU.
The Labour leader has gone further than any prime minister since the 2016 vote by saying he wants to see the U.K. rejoin the EU in his lifetime. He’ll head to Brussels for the Nov. 20 summit where he is expected to sign agreements on agri-food trade, emissions trading and a youth mobility scheme, and has opened the door to rejoining the single market, customs union or even the EU itself.
But the City so far sees these suggestions as political posturing rather than an imminent reality it must plan for.
Playing politics
The discussion is “farfetched,” said a third lobbyist who works across the EU and U.K., adding their firm won’t engage until Burnham’s proposals are more than rhetoric.
“The political hurdles are pretty legitimate,” the same lobbyist said of rejoining. “What will the EU want to extract and will the U.K. accept?”
Since the referendum, many financial firms have relocated substantial sums and staff to the continent so they can continue serving EU customers.
“There’s a lot of sunk costs in what everybody has done to get business ready,” the lobbyist said.
There’s little appetite to reopen the old fights or endure more years of disruption — especially with fears London could fall behind the U.S. in technological innovation.
“It took several years to leave, it will take several years to re-enter,” said a City lawyer. “Can we afford that level of distraction?”
With the City broadly content with a nimbler, streamlined domestic rulebook, there is also reluctance to rejoin the Brussels rule‑making machine.
“In an ideal world, you’d have market access and your own rules, but that is not possible,” the lawyer said, referring to the red line that adopting EU rules would be required to gain access to the single market.
It’s a lesson the City learned the hard way after Brexit when, despite similar rulebooks, the EU would not allow U.K. firms to “cherry‑pick” access once they left the bloc.
And despite the City’s continued efforts and a recent deal with Switzerland that lets firms operate there while following the U.K.’s regulatory framework, the EU is unlikely to soften that principle.
Paulina Dejmek Hack, a former senior aide to EU Brexit negotiator Michel Barnier who worked on talks with the U.K., is now director general of the European Commission’s financial‑services department (DG FISMA), making her the key EU official for the City.
“She’ll be very orthodox,” said a fourth lobbyist with an EU‑U.K. role. “She’s not going to do a deal like that.”
Toss up
Still, while the City may be wary of Burnham’s rhetoric and reluctant to engage early, the economic prize of unfettered market access could ultimately outweigh new domestic rules.
“If it comes down to it, I don’t think the City would come out strongly against rejoin,” the second lobbyist said.
There could be sharp divisions. Conversations within firms and associations haven’t moved far yet, and the industry could split — even within businesses — over who benefits.
“Parts of a business may be relying on a quirk to make more money, but more profitable parts of the business may want to rejoin,” the second lobbyist said.
“There won’t be consensus and there won’t be a huge appetite to jump back in,” added the banking lobbyist, who nevertheless said the industry should be prepared if the Treasury comes knocking.